|
It is not because things are difficult that we do not dare; it is because we do not dare that things are difficult. — Seneca
This is more of a concept than a plan. It is offered in the hope it will inspire a communal effort to reverse the downward global spiral that began on 9/11. It has developed over many years and every angle has been analyzed and researched. The whole purpose is to encourage examination and discussion of what is possible and how it could be a start to reforming our world. One of the keys to this proposal is that it would greatly enhance the elements of the site that are there today. And far from being a drain on a struggling city, it would be the greatest visitor draw imaginable. Even though there are already towers taller than 2000 feet in other countries, with ever taller towers sure to follow, the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center would always be the most celebrated towers on Earth. The following outline will be linked to pages that provide more details, background, and documentation. But the proposal can be fully understood by reading the text on this page, following the concise history on the page before. When it is finished, the forward and back page links will consecutively move through the entire scope of what is being proposed. It will then be ready to submit to the President and leaders in Congress — to bring to the American People. ☙ THE TWIN TOWERS would rise two thousand feet above their footprints and soar over Lower Manhattan as the original towers once did. They would be the first megatall towers in our hemisphere and feature two of the tallest outdoor rooftop decks in the world. (At this time, they would be the tallest.) They would be golden to represent their original dedication as “a monument to world peace” and to the Golden Rule as humanity’s North Star. Or they could retain the original silver façade with golden tracing added to symbolize the alchemy that transforming the World Trade Center could have on the future of America and the world. We envision towers that would fill the original footprints, which could be done without crowding the site or disturbing the infrastructure below. We don’t pretend to know the structural requirements of building that high, but we are sure that by employing the supremely confident, creative, and resolute spirit that built the originals and the advanced technology of today it can be done. The Twin Towers were heroic architecture, the epitome of a daring, confident culture. Only greater Twin Towers could ever live up to the indelible imprint they made on our world. Developing ☙ THE 9/11 MEMORIAL would stretch along West Street, from Liberty to Fulton Streets, with the parapets arranged to the north and the south of a central Tomb of the Unknowns, forming a solemn precinct — as it is The memorial pools have served an important function since 2011, but it is time to start looking up instead of down. As one of the early comments on our petition pointed out: “Nothing has rewarded the jihadists more than the ongoing sight of a world landmark wiped off the face of the earth.” And that continues to be true. The memorial was chosen, from over 5,000 competition entries, to sanitize the site from all vestiges of the brutal destruction. Even the victims’ names were meant to be located at the base of the pools so as not to scare off future tenants. But officials had to relent after 9/11 families and friends held a three-week-long overnight vigil on the frigid sidewalk in front of the firehouse on Liberty Street demanding the names be brought above ground. Developing ☙ THE 9/11 MUSEUM would be moved to the cavernous base of the Freedom Tower. That would be in keeping with the tower’s obelisk shape — an international funereal element — rising at One World Trade Center. Standing beside the new memorial, with the unidentified remains lying in repose, the victims’ names flanking the tomb on either side, the flags flying, and the Eternal Flame bearing constant witness, the symbolism becomes entirely fitting and uplifting. As the new home to the 9/11 Museum, with the exhibits transferred from their underground location to the cavernous space behind the concrete base. The observatory, dedicated as a 9/11 Hall of Heroes, would include meeting rooms, exhibition and auditorium spaces, and a private space for victims’ loved ones to look down on the dignified Memorial and find peace. And the elevator panorama would be changed to reflect a celebration of Freedom through Americans’ 250 years of sacrifice since 1776. ☙ THE KOENIG SPHERE would stand at the entrance to the solemn precinct. It would revolve on a small version of its original fountain base and lining either side of the approach to the Memorial precinct would be uplifting fountain jets behind glass barriers to cut down on wind and spray. German artist Fritz Koenig was commissioned to design a sculpture dedicated to World Peace through World Trade. It satin the center of a 90-foot wide fountain in the plaza between the Towers and rotated once every 24 hours. It was the only WTC structure to miraculously survive the destruction of 9/11 and was later rehabilitated as much as it could be by its creator. There was tremendous popular support for returning it to the Plaza, where it would have been an inspiring icon of the American spirit of overcoming. But it was too evocative and authentic for the corporate rebuilding agenda. After years of tireless lobbying to “Save The Sphere” by 9/11 Family Member Michael Burke it was located across the street in Liberty Park. ☙ THE PLAZA suffers from an inevitable lack of reverence due to spreading the Memorial all over the 8-acre quadrant. The project was geared to making the Plaza attractive commercially instead of authentic and stirring. It is not uplifting because it was not meant to be. That perverse incentive is evident in the Port Authority’s marketing use of the word “campus” when referring to a site where thousands of people were savagely murdered — as if it were just another Silicon Valley corporate spread. The TTA plan concentrates the Memorial and Museum at the west end of the site, while the property to the east is open to the mundane enjoyment of life. With an alabaster Tomb of the Unknowns at the far end of the broad avenue that runs from the east to the west of the quadrant, the two massive tridents, 9/11 flag, and Eternal Flame there would be a sense of sanctity. Beyond the First Responders’ Glade would be the flags of every nation that lost a citizen flying from flagpoles that run along the western edge of the site and around the corners of Liberty and Fulton Streets. A plaque with the respective names of the citizens would be at the base of each flagpole. The functions of the two utility structures along West Street would be relocated and the Snohetta Pavilion would be dismantled, since it no longer be needed when the Museum is transferred. A well-defined Memorial precinct will be formed by arranging the bronze parapets with the names (maintaining the meaningful adjacencies) on either side of the vault. And on the outside of the two entrance walls into the precinct would be inscribed the expanding list of names (with ranks) of every one who has fallen as a result of their valorous service on 9/11 and/or their work to remove the infernal “Pile” of destruction. With a noble 9/11 Memorial concentrated at the west end of the site and the 9/11 Museum right next to it, the sprawling, hybrid quality of the current Memorial will make way for legitimate places of celebration and recreation. Umbrellaed tables opposite the Oculus would be popular gathering places before heading into the Performing Arts complex or back to work in the World Trade Center offices. Open-air events could include concerts, movies, seasonal pop-up shops, and even a winter rink. ☙ THE ROOFTOPS of both Towers would be open-air public spaces while the 1776 beacon would flash on the Freedom Tower. Additional broadcast transmission could be inserted below the Twins’ rooflines. A Port Authority ad in the 1980s for the rooftop observation deck cautioned: “And after dark, please don’t touch the stars.” That epitomized the Towers’ allure. And there is nothing in the city or country or world today that can come close to that appeal. Visitors to the original Towers will remember their disappointment when bad weather meant that a “Roof Closed” sign stretch across the Observatory escalator to the roofdeck. No matter how high, an indoor observatory is definitely a consolation prize. With two rooftops for the public to enjoy, one could be part of the restaurant and catering functions in Tower One and the other the “Top of the World” observatory and cafe in Tower Two. The highest public open-air observation deck is currently at 1,840 ft. at the the top of the Clock Tower in Makkah, Saudi Arabia. But even when the Twin Tops are surpassed as the highest outdoor decks on earth, they would surely continue to be the most spectacular. ☙ THE BELLS were the central feature of a very imaginative memorial that was being planned in Texas around 2008. The “World Memorial” organization reached out to Ken Gardner of Twin Towers II to suggest blending their ideas for a memorial with the Belton-Gardner plan. What was most memorable about the “World Memorial”, which was founded by American Airlines pilot Brus Messenger and Firefighter Mitch Mendler, was that it included the largest carillon in the world. The idea of a full carillon suspended between the flagpoles, chiming every hour, when the birthday roses are placed, or when a name is added to the outer wall, adds a dimension to the Memorial that would be lovely and moving. ☙ THE FUNDING is the keystone of the proposal. If it is not viable, neither is the plan. But we are very confident the following program will open a lot of eyes to the realm of what is possible. It is complex, so we will therefore develop it on the detailed page first and then write the summary later. Developing ☙ THE DREAM Carl Sandburg wrote: “The Republic is a dream. Nothing happens unless first a dream.” And, “Dream No Small Dreams” was the byword of the man who spearheaded the World Trade Center project in 1962, Executive Director of the Port Authority Austin J. Tobin. He may have been thinking of the words of Daniel Burnham, the Chicago architect and urban planner who designed the Flatiron Building in New York and was instrumental in the development of the skyscraper: “Make no little plans. They have no magic to stir men’s blood…” — or of the better known quote of German Poet/Philosopher/Statesman Goethe: “Dream no small dreams, for they have no power to move the hearts of men.” But in any case, they were the words that built the Twin Towers. On the 50th anniversary of their formal opening the TTA posted: “On this Golden Anniversary of the World Trade Center’s opening on April 4, 1973, we affirm our belief in its founding vision as ‘a living symbol of man’s dedication to world peace… a representation of man’s belief in humanity, his need for individual dignity, his belief in the cooperation of men, and, through cooperation, his ability to find greatness.’ We believe in the dream of a Golden Age of Brotherhood and our faith is strong that restoring the Twin Towers’ transcendent presence in the world’s skyline would be a triumph for humanity and the surest way to a better world.” And so we do. When Philippe Petit, one of the earliest signers of the Twin Towers Alliance petition, spent almost an hour dancing on a wire between the Twin Towers in 1974, he epitomized the courage and joy that dreaming-no-small-dreams requires and inspires. What many might call a death wish, he calls “a life wish.” When Mr. Petit accepted an award at the 2008 Sundance Festival ceremonies for his work on “Man on Wire,” he urged everyone to: “keep moving mountains, keep growing wings, keep dreaming…” Developing   
|
